"You may have heard of civil asset forfeiture.
That's where police can seize your property and cash without first proving you committed a crime; without a warrant and without arresting you, as long as they suspect that your property is somehow tied to a crime.
Now, the Oklahoma Highway Patrol has a device that also allows them to seize money in your bank account or on prepaid cards.
It's called an ERAD, or Electronic Recovery and Access to Data machine, and state police began using 16 of them last month. "
In other words, the cops can drain your bank account on the side of the road while they pull you over for a tail light ticket, which may not even be out. Just that they "Thought" it was out when they looked.
Further in story we find this little gem.
""If you can prove can prove that you have a legitimate reason to have that money it will be given back to you. And we've done that in the past," Vincent said about any money seized. "
Excuse me? I have to "PROVE" that I'm not doing anything illegal? Is that like trying to prove a negative? How would you do that? And why is the burden of such proof on the Citizen instead of on the Officer to PROVE that the funds are illegal? Innocent until proven guilty by a court of law. Isn't that how it's SUPPOSED to go?
And here is the kicker of the whole deal for me.
"News 9 obtained a copy of the contract with the state.
It shows the state is paying ERAD Group Inc., $5,000 for the software and scanners, then 7.7 percent of all the cash the highway patrol seizes."
ERAD Group Inc. get a cut of the money in addition to being paid for the machines and the software. Is this like the Red Light Cameras then?
H/t Kenny aka Wirecutter and Jeffrey
Showing posts with label asset forfeiture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label asset forfeiture. Show all posts
Thursday, June 9, 2016
Thursday, June 18, 2015
Asset Forfeiture - When Vox says it out of hand
"Charles Clarke entered the Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky International Airport last February eager to go back to his mother after a months-long visit with relatives. But instead of a quick, easy trip home to Orlando, Clarke lost his life savings — $11,000 in cash — to law enforcement officials who never even proved he committed a crime.
Clarke, a 24-year-old college student, said losing that $11,000 was "devastating." He's been forced to live with his mom, trumping his plans to move closer to school. He's fallen back on other family for financial support. And he had to take out loans for school instead of paying for it up front — for which he's still in debt. "It's been a struggle for me," Clarke, who's now fighting in court to get his money back, said.
But law enforcement officials may have been working within the confines of the law when they took Clarke's money. Under federal and state laws that allow what's called "civil forfeiture," law enforcement officers can seize someone's property without proving the person was guilty of a crime; they just need probable cause to believe the assets are being used as part of criminal activity, typically drug trafficking. Police can then absorb the value of this property — be it cash, cars, guns, or something else — as profit: either through state programs, or under a federal program known as Equitable Sharing that lets local and state police get up to 80 percent of the value of what they seize as money for their departments."
I'm sorry but the burden of proof should be on the Cops taking the money or other item, NOT the person who it was seized from.
Law Enforcement should have to PROVE beyond a Reasonable Doubt, and that is the problem. The burden of proof is set so low, the cops could take anything they want, and there are no repercussions. They don't have to pay for a lawyer to fight. The person the money or items were taken from has to.
I have a novel new idea, if the money or item is found NOT to be from criminal activities, the Police Department has to pay the person who they seized it from, legal fees, ALL of their Fees. And it comes out of their budget, not from their City or County or State's budget. Their DEPARTMENT BUDGET. And the individual officer also have to pay a percentage out of their own pocket as well.
All it would take would be one judge to say that the taking was wrong and the department and any officer involved, would have to pay the legal fees of the person who the stuff was seized from. Also any Prosecutor or DA involved would also have to pay personally. I bet if that precedent was set, many of these GIGO seizures would stop very quickly.
H/t Kenny
Clarke, a 24-year-old college student, said losing that $11,000 was "devastating." He's been forced to live with his mom, trumping his plans to move closer to school. He's fallen back on other family for financial support. And he had to take out loans for school instead of paying for it up front — for which he's still in debt. "It's been a struggle for me," Clarke, who's now fighting in court to get his money back, said.
But law enforcement officials may have been working within the confines of the law when they took Clarke's money. Under federal and state laws that allow what's called "civil forfeiture," law enforcement officers can seize someone's property without proving the person was guilty of a crime; they just need probable cause to believe the assets are being used as part of criminal activity, typically drug trafficking. Police can then absorb the value of this property — be it cash, cars, guns, or something else — as profit: either through state programs, or under a federal program known as Equitable Sharing that lets local and state police get up to 80 percent of the value of what they seize as money for their departments."
I'm sorry but the burden of proof should be on the Cops taking the money or other item, NOT the person who it was seized from.
Law Enforcement should have to PROVE beyond a Reasonable Doubt, and that is the problem. The burden of proof is set so low, the cops could take anything they want, and there are no repercussions. They don't have to pay for a lawyer to fight. The person the money or items were taken from has to.
I have a novel new idea, if the money or item is found NOT to be from criminal activities, the Police Department has to pay the person who they seized it from, legal fees, ALL of their Fees. And it comes out of their budget, not from their City or County or State's budget. Their DEPARTMENT BUDGET. And the individual officer also have to pay a percentage out of their own pocket as well.
All it would take would be one judge to say that the taking was wrong and the department and any officer involved, would have to pay the legal fees of the person who the stuff was seized from. Also any Prosecutor or DA involved would also have to pay personally. I bet if that precedent was set, many of these GIGO seizures would stop very quickly.
H/t Kenny
Monday, January 19, 2015
Asset Forfeiture just became harder for Law Enforcement.
US Attorney General Eric Holder just dis-incentivized the Federal Asset Forfeiture program that allowed Law Enforcement to trap you into allowing them to search your car then seizing any thing of value you might have.
"In Post’s a series of exposes titled, “Your property is guilty until you prove it innocent,” the policy allows law enforcement’s perspective to force the owners to “prove” all the seized property was legally acquired in order to recover any assets.
Journalists documented from Justice Department data obtained through Freedom of Information Act requests that “local and state police routinely pulled over drivers for minor traffic infractions, pressed them to agree to warrantless searches and seized large amounts of cash without evidence of wrongdoing.” The aggressive style of policing, called “highway interdiction,” involved authorities seizing money and property during routine traffic stops, that left thousands of people not indicted for criminal activity, but forced to fight protracted legal battles to regain their money and cars.
The Post found evidence that police were spending the confiscation proceeds with little oversight to buy luxury cars, assault weapons, military-grade gear and armored cars."
What this will mean until it gets spread around to all the various agencies is anybodies guess.
Maybe now there can be an accounting of just what has been taken and from whom. And to allow for the possibility that innocent people can regain their funds and possessions or at least a settlement from the agency that took their property.
"In Post’s a series of exposes titled, “Your property is guilty until you prove it innocent,” the policy allows law enforcement’s perspective to force the owners to “prove” all the seized property was legally acquired in order to recover any assets.
Journalists documented from Justice Department data obtained through Freedom of Information Act requests that “local and state police routinely pulled over drivers for minor traffic infractions, pressed them to agree to warrantless searches and seized large amounts of cash without evidence of wrongdoing.” The aggressive style of policing, called “highway interdiction,” involved authorities seizing money and property during routine traffic stops, that left thousands of people not indicted for criminal activity, but forced to fight protracted legal battles to regain their money and cars.
The Post found evidence that police were spending the confiscation proceeds with little oversight to buy luxury cars, assault weapons, military-grade gear and armored cars."
What this will mean until it gets spread around to all the various agencies is anybodies guess.
Maybe now there can be an accounting of just what has been taken and from whom. And to allow for the possibility that innocent people can regain their funds and possessions or at least a settlement from the agency that took their property.
Tuesday, October 7, 2014
Monday, September 8, 2014
Reason has an article about the Washington Post on Asset Forfeiture
How law enforcement agencies abuse asset forfeiture laws to bankroll their various budgets to the tune of billions is the focus of a big three-part investigation at The Washington Post. Two parts have been published already; the third part will be published Tuesday.
The first two articles are excerpted and linked below.
The first article
"Local officers, county deputies and state troopers were encouraged to act more aggressively in searching for suspicious people, drugs and other contraband. The departments of Homeland Security and Justice spent millions on police training.
The effort succeeded, but it had an impact that has been largely hidden from public view: the spread of an aggressive brand of policing that has spurred the seizure of hundreds of millions of dollars in cash from motorists and others not charged with crimes, a Washington Post investigation found. Thousands of people have been forced to fight legal battles that can last more than a year to get their money back."
The second article.
"David had developed an uncanny talent for finding cocaine and cash in cars and trucks, beginning along the remote highways of the Mojave Desert. His reputation had spread among police officers after he started a training firm in 1989 to teach his homegrown stop-and-seizure techniques. He called it Desert Snow.
The demonstration he gave on Capitol Hill in November 2003 startled onlookers with the many ways smugglers and terrorists can hide contraband, cash and even weapons of mass destruction in vehicles. It also made David’s name in Washington and launched his firm into the fast-expanding marketplace for homeland security, where it would thrive in an atmosphere of fear and help shape law enforcement on highways in every corner of the country."
The first two articles are excerpted and linked below.
The first article
"Local officers, county deputies and state troopers were encouraged to act more aggressively in searching for suspicious people, drugs and other contraband. The departments of Homeland Security and Justice spent millions on police training.
The effort succeeded, but it had an impact that has been largely hidden from public view: the spread of an aggressive brand of policing that has spurred the seizure of hundreds of millions of dollars in cash from motorists and others not charged with crimes, a Washington Post investigation found. Thousands of people have been forced to fight legal battles that can last more than a year to get their money back."
The second article.
"David had developed an uncanny talent for finding cocaine and cash in cars and trucks, beginning along the remote highways of the Mojave Desert. His reputation had spread among police officers after he started a training firm in 1989 to teach his homegrown stop-and-seizure techniques. He called it Desert Snow.
The demonstration he gave on Capitol Hill in November 2003 startled onlookers with the many ways smugglers and terrorists can hide contraband, cash and even weapons of mass destruction in vehicles. It also made David’s name in Washington and launched his firm into the fast-expanding marketplace for homeland security, where it would thrive in an atmosphere of fear and help shape law enforcement on highways in every corner of the country."
Wednesday, October 10, 2012
Texas schools implementing RFID tracking of students
"A school district in Texas came under fire earlier this year when it announced that it would require students to wear microchip-embedded ID cards at all times. Now students who refuse to be monitored say they are feeling the repercussions."
Hmmm in this state in the so-called "Bible Belt" these school administrators don't see issues with this? Or with the Fourth Amendment? If my children's school went to this, their school would lose the funding they receive for having my kids there. I would pull them out of the school and either homeschool them or find some way to afford a private school for them. This is just so wrong on many levels.
Here is a Data Point for the school administrators. Many Christians believe RFID Tracking Technology is the first step to the mark of the Beast, you know the Devil, Lucifer, Satan. Let me give you a refresher.
"And that no man might buy or sell, save he that had the mark, or the name of the beast, or the number of his name.(Revelation 13:17)"
So the kids can't get lunch, they can't attend school functions, they can't do anything without carrying the little RFID card.
And you administrators don't see what is wrong with this?
What school did you get your degree from? Are we sure it's not from one of those degree factories where you send in some money and some cereal box tops to get your handy dandy accredited degree?
Someone doesn't seem to understand that a lot of your students are from very religious families. Families who DO read their Bible, and DO believe what it says.
Now how about the Fourth Amendment issues. This card is to "Track" the students whereabouts. Who said the school will stop "Tracking" the students as soon as they go off campus? What about the bathroom? Or the Nurses Office? Supposedly this is to "relax the rampant truancy rates devastating the state’s school and the subsequent funding they are failing to receive as a result", so this is about money to them. They only see this as about money. Hmmm, let me post a few other things that are just about money.
"LAPD Joins Feds In Skirting Fourth Amendment With Cell Phone Tracking Devices"
"Federal court OKs warrantless cell phone tracking by police"
"Unwarranted Intrusion: GPS and the Fourth Amendment"
Do you want more? Now you might read those and say "How are those about money?" All I will say to that is
ASSET FORFEITURE
Need I continue?
Government Entities have tracked citizens without warrants, without consent, all for money.
And when you try to fight back and assert your rights, well I'll let the parent of a student fighting against these RFID card for religious reasons reply.
"The girl’s father, Steve Hernandez, tells WND that the school has been somewhat willing to work with the daughter’s demands, but insists that her family “would have to agree to stop criticizing the program” and start publicly supporting it
.
“I told him that was unacceptable because it would imply an endorsement of the district’s policy and my daughter and I should not have to give up our constitutional rights to speak out against a program that we feel is wrong,” Mr. Hernandez responded."
Read that again... "Would have to agree to stop criticizing the program, and start publicly supporting it" In other words, we'll listen to what you have to say when you shut up and start spewing our message. And Spew is right. I wonder if they intentionally decided to emulate Nancy "You have to pass it to know what's in it" Pelosi.
H/t Kenny - Wirecutter
Hmmm in this state in the so-called "Bible Belt" these school administrators don't see issues with this? Or with the Fourth Amendment? If my children's school went to this, their school would lose the funding they receive for having my kids there. I would pull them out of the school and either homeschool them or find some way to afford a private school for them. This is just so wrong on many levels.
Here is a Data Point for the school administrators. Many Christians believe RFID Tracking Technology is the first step to the mark of the Beast, you know the Devil, Lucifer, Satan. Let me give you a refresher.
"And that no man might buy or sell, save he that had the mark, or the name of the beast, or the number of his name.(Revelation 13:17)"
So the kids can't get lunch, they can't attend school functions, they can't do anything without carrying the little RFID card.
And you administrators don't see what is wrong with this?
What school did you get your degree from? Are we sure it's not from one of those degree factories where you send in some money and some cereal box tops to get your handy dandy accredited degree?
Someone doesn't seem to understand that a lot of your students are from very religious families. Families who DO read their Bible, and DO believe what it says.
Now how about the Fourth Amendment issues. This card is to "Track" the students whereabouts. Who said the school will stop "Tracking" the students as soon as they go off campus? What about the bathroom? Or the Nurses Office? Supposedly this is to "relax the rampant truancy rates devastating the state’s school and the subsequent funding they are failing to receive as a result", so this is about money to them. They only see this as about money. Hmmm, let me post a few other things that are just about money.
"LAPD Joins Feds In Skirting Fourth Amendment With Cell Phone Tracking Devices"
"Federal court OKs warrantless cell phone tracking by police"
"Unwarranted Intrusion: GPS and the Fourth Amendment"
Do you want more? Now you might read those and say "How are those about money?" All I will say to that is
ASSET FORFEITURE
Need I continue?
Government Entities have tracked citizens without warrants, without consent, all for money.
And when you try to fight back and assert your rights, well I'll let the parent of a student fighting against these RFID card for religious reasons reply.
"The girl’s father, Steve Hernandez, tells WND that the school has been somewhat willing to work with the daughter’s demands, but insists that her family “would have to agree to stop criticizing the program” and start publicly supporting it
.
“I told him that was unacceptable because it would imply an endorsement of the district’s policy and my daughter and I should not have to give up our constitutional rights to speak out against a program that we feel is wrong,” Mr. Hernandez responded."
Read that again... "Would have to agree to stop criticizing the program, and start publicly supporting it" In other words, we'll listen to what you have to say when you shut up and start spewing our message. And Spew is right. I wonder if they intentionally decided to emulate Nancy "You have to pass it to know what's in it" Pelosi.
H/t Kenny - Wirecutter
Saturday, September 8, 2012
How does this pass Constitutional Muster?
"The Obama administration is making it easier for bureaucrats to take away guns without offering the accused any realistic due process. In a final rule published last week, the Justice Department granted the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) authority to “seize and administratively forfeit property involved in controlled-substance abuses.” That means government can grab firearms and other property from someone who has never been convicted or even charged with any crime."
Seriously? The ATF now has the power to use civil forfeiture to take anything you own without EVER charging you with a crime?
How is this legal?
And why hasn't it been challenged?
H/t Mike Vanderboegh Sipsey Street Irregulars
Seriously? The ATF now has the power to use civil forfeiture to take anything you own without EVER charging you with a crime?
How is this legal?
And why hasn't it been challenged?
H/t Mike Vanderboegh Sipsey Street Irregulars
Thursday, September 6, 2012
More on Asset Forfeiture
"While most Americans go about their rat-race lives and focus on being
entertained by an endless stream of sports and imaginary lives on
silver screen and monitor, insidious threats creep ever closer.
Most will not believe what I’m about to write. Many will deny that our property rights are under attack regardless of the proof surrounding us online – even though they could confirm it for themselves – IF they only would."
H/t Pissed - The Feral Irishman
Most will not believe what I’m about to write. Many will deny that our property rights are under attack regardless of the proof surrounding us online – even though they could confirm it for themselves – IF they only would."
H/t Pissed - The Feral Irishman
Wednesday, August 29, 2012
War on Drugs is now a war on Money
You are buying a car. You go to the bank and get out the money you worked hard for a year to save so you could buy this car. You ask a friend for a ride, as you don't have a car. For some reason your friend gets pulled over by the cops. The next thing you know, your hard earned money is being seized and you can't get it back. This is happening all over the US and Eric Holder and the BATFEIEIO want to make it much easier for them to do it.
"Attorney General Eric Holder has granted the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) authority, for a one-year trial period, to seize and administratively forfeit property allegedly involved in controlled substance offenses pursuant to United States Code Title 21 › Chapter 13 › Subchapter I › Part E › § 881."
"Attorney General Eric Holder has granted the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) authority, for a one-year trial period, to seize and administratively forfeit property allegedly involved in controlled substance offenses pursuant to United States Code Title 21 › Chapter 13 › Subchapter I › Part E › § 881."
Thursday, August 23, 2012
I find this very disturbing
"Town Plans to Raise Revenue By Combining Drug-Sniffing Dogs With Asset Forfeiture
Orin Kerr • August 22, 2012 11:33 pm
They say a dog is man’s best friend, and the town of Henry, Tennessee is hoping that dogs can help the town raise revenue in tough times:"
Cities and towns are looking at asset forfeiture laws as a checkbook or a credit card for the Police departments. What part of "To Protect and To Serve" do they not understand? Evidently the new motto they adhere to is "To Seize and Disburse"
Orin Kerr • August 22, 2012 11:33 pm
They say a dog is man’s best friend, and the town of Henry, Tennessee is hoping that dogs can help the town raise revenue in tough times:"
Cities and towns are looking at asset forfeiture laws as a checkbook or a credit card for the Police departments. What part of "To Protect and To Serve" do they not understand? Evidently the new motto they adhere to is "To Seize and Disburse"
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)